Research Progress on Gauging Methods for RemainingLiquid Propellant in Orbit
1.State Key Laboratory of Multiphase Flow in Powering Engineering,School of Energy and Power Engineering, Xi’an Jiaotong University,Xi’an 710049, China;2.School of Mechanical Engineering,Xi’an Jiaotong University,Xi’an 710049,China
DAI Bin1,LIU Qi1,ZHENG You-you1,LIANG Yan1,FAN Liang-liang2,ZHAO Liang1. Research Progress on Gauging Methods for RemainingLiquid Propellant in Orbit[J]. Journal of Propulsion Technology, 2019, 40(12): 2641-2654.
[1] 袁 磊, 王 申, 连仁志, 等. 一种推进剂剩余量在轨测量方法研究[J]. 火箭推进, 2013, 39(5): 87-91.
[2] Feller J, Kashani A, Khasin M, et al. Spectral Mass Gauging of Unsettled Liquid with Acoustic Waves[J]. Materials Science and Engineering , 2017, 278(1): 1-9.
[3] Levine Darren , Wise Brian , Schulman Richard , et al. Surface Tension and Contact Angle Analysis with Design of Propellant Measurement Apparatus[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power, 2015, 31(1): 429-443.
[4] 郭建玲, 王慧玉, 王宏年. 低重力下预报推进剂剩余量的探索[J]. 推进技术, 1996, 17(5): 76-79. (GUO Jian-ling, WANG Hui-yu, WANG Hong-nian. Research on Propellant Remaining Estimation in Low-Gravity [J]. Journal of Propulsion Technology, 1996, 17(5): 76-79.)
[5] Hartwig J W. Propellant Management Devices for Low-Gravity Fluid Management: Past, Present, and Future Applications[J]. Journal of Spacecraft & Rockets, 2017, 54(4): 1-17.
[6] Tam W , Behruzi P , Jaekle D , et al. The Evolutionary Forces and the Design and Development of Propellant Management Devices for Space Flight in Europe and the United States[C]. Rome: 5th Space Propulsion, 2016.
[7] Evans R L, Olivier J R. Proposal for Determining the Mass of Liquid Propellant within a Space Vehicle Propellant Tank Subjected to a Zero Gravity Environment[R]. NASA-TN-D-1571, 1963.
[8] Wakeman J F, Burns B. Zero-Gravity Radiotracer Propellant Gauge[C]. San Francisco: 2th AIAA Annual Meeting, 1965.
[9] Bupp F E. Zero-G Flight Test of a Gauging System . Volume 1: Summary[R]. NASA-CR-147707, 1976.
[10] Monti R. Assessment Study of Liquid Content Measurement Methods Applicable to Space Missions[R]. Techno System Report TS-8-84, 1984.
[11] Trinks H, Behring T. Liquid Propellant Content Measurement Methods Applicable to Space Missions[R]. AIAA89-2720.
[12] YEH, Tso P. Bipropellant Propulsion Performance and Propellant-Remaining Prediction for INSAT-1B[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power, 1992, 8(1): 74-79.
[13] Torgovitsky S. Propellant Remaining Modeling[R]. N 92-14096.
[14] Challoner A D. Determination of Spacecraft Liquid Fill Fraction[R]. AIAA93-3727(-CP.
[15] Yendler B. Review of Propellant Gauging Methods[R]. AIAA2006-939.
[16] 潘海林, 丁凤林, 李 永, 等. 空间推进[M]. 西安:西北工业大学出版社, 2016.
[17] 王 伟, 谢成山. 俄罗斯航天发展规划的实施和调整[J]. 国防科技工业, 2012, 19(9): 70-71.
[18] 吴燕生. 中国航天发展的新纪元[J]. 导弹与航天运载技术, 2004, 33(1): 1-2.
[19] 尚小桦, 何继伟. 日本JAXA 2025规划及其航天发展的新动向[J]. 中国航天, 2006, 29(3): 24-28.
[20] Nazario Victor , Ramirez Jaime , Kulkarni Mandar , et al. Mass Gauging and Validation of a Novel In-Space Propellant Storage and Transfer Using CFD[R]. AIAA2017-5198.
[21] Ambrose J, Yendler B, Collicott S H. Modeling to Evaluate a Spacecraft Propellant Gauging System[J]. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 2000, 37(6): 833-835.
[22] Yendler B, Collicott S H , Martin T A . Thermal Gauging and Rebalancing of Propellant in Multiple Tank Satellites[J]. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 2007, 44(4): 878-883.
[23] Yendler B, Narita T. Thermal Propellant Gauging System for BSS 601[R]. AIAA2007-3149.
[24] Yendler B. Unconventional Thermal Propellant Gauging System[R]. AIAA2007-1363.
[25] Aparicio A, Yendler B. Thermal Propellant Gauging at EOL, Telstar 11 Implementation[R]. AIAA2008-3375.
[26] Chang Y, Chae Y, Young M, et al. Error Analysis of Spacecraft Propellant Gauging Techniques[R]. AIAA94-2792.
[27] 宋 涛, 马云华, 林长杰, 等. 环境对气体注入法测量剩余推进剂的影响分析[J]. 航天器工程, 2011, 20(4): 147-151.
[28] 宋 涛, 梁军强, 魏延明. 结合多种剩余推进剂测量方法的应用研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2012, 38(1): 58-62.
[29] 雷 雯. 国外空间液体剩余量测量技术[J]. 推进技术, 1996, 17(3): 83-86. (LEI Wen. Technologies of Liquid Gauging in Space[J]. Journal of Propulsion Technology, 1996, 17(3): 83-86.)
[30] Dresar N T V. PVT Gauging with Liquid Nitrogen[J]. Cryogenics, 2006, 46(2-3): 118-125.
[31] Lal A, Raghunandan B N. Uncertainty Analysis of Propellant Gauging System for Spacecraft[J]. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 2005, 42(5): 943-946.
[32] Wang L, Ye S, Ma Y , et al. CFD Investigation on Helium Pressurization Behaviors in Liquid Hydrogen Tank [J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2017, 42(52): 30792-30803.
[33] Yendler B S, Molinsky J, Chernikov S, et al. Comparison of Gauging Methods for Orbital’s GEOStarTM 1 Satellites[R]. AIAA2014-1810.
[34] Dresar N T V. An Uncertainty Analysis of The PVT Gauging Method Applied to Sub-Critical Cryogenic Propellant Tanks [J]. Cryogenics, 2004, 44(6-8): 515-523.
[35] Seo M, Jeong S, Jung Y S, et al. Improved Pressure-Volume-Temperature Method for Estimation of Cryogenic Liquid Volume [J]. Cryogenics, 2012, 52(4-6).
[36] Seo M, Park H, Yoo D G, et al. Experimental Investigation of Pressure-Volume-Temperature Mass Gauging Method under Microgravity Condition by Parabolic Flight[J]. Physics Procedia, 2015, 67(6): 258-263.
[37] Benthem R C, Es J V, Put P V, et al. Accuracy Analysis of Propellant Gauging Systems[R]. AIAA2013-3300.
[38] Dandaleix L, Ounougha L, Jallade S. Flight Validation of the Thermal Propellant Gauging Method Used at EADS Astrium[C]. Sardina: 4th International Spacecraft Propulsion Conference, 2004.
[39] Hasan D, Jaeger M, Oren A, et al. Application of Satellite Hydrazine Propulsion System In-Orbit Monitoring Model[C]. Sardinia: 4th International Spacecraft Propulsion Conference, 2004.
[40] Hufenbach B. Comparative Assessment of Gauging Systems and Description of a Liquid Level Gauging Concept for a Spin Stabilized Spacecraft[C]. Noordwijk: Second European Spacecraft Propulsion Conference, 1997.
[41] 张天平, 达道安, 姜万顺, 等. 有机结合PVT和BK法以降低测量卫星液体推进剂的不确定度[J]. 推进技术, 1998, 19(4): 87-90.
[42] Myers Mike , Chilelli Nick , Yendler Boris S , et al. Implementation of Thermal Gauging Method for ABS 1A (LM 3000) Satellite[R]. AIAA2016-2458.
[43] Yendler B. Implementation of Thermal Gauging Method for SpaceBus 3000A (ArabSat 2B)[C]. Stockholm: SpaceOps 2012 Conference, 2012.
[44] Yendler B, Chernikov S, Naiyroshi R, et al. Implementation of Thermal Gauging Method for Orbital Sciences Corporation’s GEOStartm1Satellite[R]. AIAA2013-5452.
[45] Yendler B, Chernikov S, Naiyroshi R, et al. Prediction of Spacecraft Remaining Life-Challenges and Achievements[R]. AIAA2013-4162.
[46] Zimmerli G A, Asipauskas M, Chen Y, et al. A Study of Fluid Interface Configurations in Exploration Vehicle Propellant Tanks[R]. AIAA2010-1294.
[47] Chandra B, Collicott S. Low Gravity Propellant Slosh Prediction Using Surface Evolver[R]. AIAA2002-3981.
[48] Yendler B. Thermal Propellant Gauging, SpaceBus 2000 (Turksat 1C) Implementation[R]. AIAA2008-7697.
[49] Owens B, Cosgrove D, Sholl M, et al. On-Orbit Propellant Estimation, Management, and Conditioning for the THEMIS Spacecraft Constellation[R]. AIAA2010-2329.
[50] 江世臣, 付 鑫, 康奥峰, 等. 基于热响应的卫星推进剂剩余量测量方法研究[J]. 上海航天, 2014, 31(3): 43-47.
[51] 胡振文, 孙克新, 艾 青, 等. 基于热响应法的航天器推进剂质量测量热模型[J]. 工程热物理学报, 2017, 38(9): 1935-1939.
[52] 郭 蕾, 李 永, 焦 焱, 等. 热容法测量推进剂剩余量的地面试验[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2018, 44(1): 74-78.
[53] 郭 蕾, 李 永, 焦 焱, 等. 基于卫星推进剂剩余量测量的热容法数值仿真[J]. 导航与控制, 2018, 17(6): 102-107.
[54] Green S, Walter D, Dodge F, et al. Ground Testing of Compression Mass Gauge[R]. AIAA2004-4151.
[55] 傅 娟, 陈小前, 黄奕勇. 测量液体推进剂剩余量的体积激励法[J]. 中国空间科学技术, 2012, 32(3).
[56] Juan Fu, Xiaoqian Chen, Yiyong Huang, et al. Validation of a Compression Mass Gauge Using Ground Tests for Liquid Propellant Mass Measurements[J]. Advances in Space Research, 2014, 53(9): 1359-1369.
[57] 王丽红, 温永刚. 低温推进剂空间质量测量技术的发展[C]. 兰州:第十届全国低温工程大会暨中国航天低温专业信息网学术交流会, 2011.
[58] Hastings Leon J, Tucker S P, Flachbart R H, et al. Marshall Space Flight Center In-Space Cryogenic Fluid Management Program Overview[R]. AIAA2005-3561
[59] Justak J F, Caimi F M, Bryant C B, et al. An Optical Mass Gauge Sensor for Zero-G Environments[J]. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, 2004, 51(1): 451-460.
[60] Doux C, Justak J. Liquid Oxygen Test Results for an Optical Mass Gauge Sensor[R]. AIAA2009-5393.
[61] Sullenberger R M, Munoz W M, Lyon M P, et al. Optical Mass Gauging System for Measuring Liquid Levels in a Reduced-Gravity Environment[J]. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 2011, 48(3): 528-533.
[62] Hansman R, Meserole J. Fundamental Limitations on Low Gravity Fluid Gauging Technologies Imposed by Orbital Mission Requirements[C]. Boston: 24th Joint Propulsion Conference, 1988.
[63] Zimmerli G, Asipauskas M, Wagner J, et al. Propellant Quantity Gauging Using the Radio Frequency Mass Gauge[R]. AIAA2011-1320.
[64] George C. Design Development and Manufacture of a Breadboard Radio Frequency Mass Gauging System[R]. NASA/CR-144C69, 1976.
[65] Zimmerli G A, Vaden K R, Herlacher M D, et al. Radio Frequency Mass Gauging of Propellants[R]. AIAA2007-1198.
[66] Zimmerli G A, Mueller C H. Compatibility of the Radio Frequency Mass Gauge with Graphite-Epoxy Composite Tanks[C]. Nashville: 62nd JANNAF Propulsion Meeting, 2015.
[67] Roberti D, Durgin W W. An Ultrasonic Measurement Technique to Determine the Location and Volume of Spherical Voids in Fluids[J]. Diabetes, 2013, 64(3):828-839.
[68] 达道安, 张天平. 在轨卫星液体推进剂测量技术评述[J]. 推进技术, 1997, 18(4): 89-94. (DA Dao-an, ZHANG Tian-ping. Introduction and Estimation on Measurement Methods of Liquid Propellant Applications to Satellites[J]. Journal of Propulsion Technology, 1997, 18(4): 89-94.)
[69] Matthijssen R, Put P. State-of-the-Art Gauging Components for Improved Propellant Management on 3-Axis Stabilized Spacecraft[R]. AIAA2006-4714.
[70] Matthijssen R, Van Put P. Ultrasonic Flow Meter for Satellite Propellant Gauging and Ground Test Facilities[R]. AIAA2008-4854.
[71] Murolo F, Pili P, Bihr C, et al. The Ultrasonic Gauging Sensors: Results of an Innovative Spacecraft Propellant Measurement Method[C]. Pasadena: 13th International Conference on Space Operations, 2014.
[72] Stephen Andrew McKim. Thermal Vacuum Test Correlation of a Zero Propellant Load Case Thermal Capacitance Propellant Gauging Analytical Model[D]. USA:Maryland, 2017.
[73] Bihr C, Murolo F, Klinc M, et al. Propellant Gauging Experience with Meteosat Second Generation S/C Fleet[C]. Marseille: 15th International Conference on Space Operations is a Aerospace and Airlines & Aviation Conference, 2018.
[74] Crosby Kevin M , Rundle Tessa , Kevin Le Captain, et al. Modal Propellant Gauging in Low Gravity[C]. USA: AIAA SPACE, 2016.
[75] Crosby Kevin M , Williams Nehemiah J , Werlink Rudolph J , et al. Modal Propellant Gauging: High-Resolution and Non-Invasive Gauging of Both Settled and Unsettled Liquids in Reduced Gravity[J]. Acta Astronautica, 2019, (2).
[76] Mendez, Omar. End of Life Propellant Estimation Using Heating Time Constants of the Tanks [C]. Daejeon: 14th International Conference on Space Operations, 2016.
[77] Dodge F T. Propellant Mass Gauging: Database of Vehicle Applications and Research and Development Studies[R]. NASA/CR-2008-215281.
[78] 达道安, 张天平. 空间液体测量技术的发展[J]. 中国空间科学技术, 1997, 17(2): 33-42.
[79] Yendler B, Chernikov S, Naiyroshi R, et al. Prediction of Spacecraft Remaining Life-Challenges and Achievements[R]. AIAA2013-4162.
[80] 达道安, 张天平. 在轨卫星液体推进剂的4种放射性测量技术[J]. 控制工程, 1996, 22(5): 27-31.
[81] Yendler B, Jew E. Total Fuel Management at EOL[R]. AIAA2008-3376.
[82] Yendler B. Active Propellant Management[R]. AIAA2006-5569.
[83] Soria-Salinas A, Zorzano M P, Martín-Torres J, et al. A Xenon Mass Gauging Through Heat Transfer Modeling for Electric Propulsion Thrusters[J]. International Journal of Mechanical, Aerospace, Industrial, Mechatronic and Manufacturing Engineering, 2017, 11(1).